Luckily, he wasn't so dense that he thought that was an actual answer to his question. Besides, he had already ruled female him out. However, judging by her reaction, she clearly knew who he was... but he wasn't who she expected him to be.

Just who was he where she was from? A criminal, most likely. Why wouldn't he be? After all, he still wasn't sure he wasn't one in his own timeline. He may be trying a different path, but he never got the redemption Ben promised in prison, and he sure as hell hadn't gotten it on the outside.

"Now that we've solved one mystery... just who are you, May?"